Repository navigation
fix: Include vector attributes in Field equality - #6934
Merged
Merged
Conversation
Re-enables the vector_index and vector_search_metric comparisons in Field.__eq__, which have been commented out since feast-dev#4855. Addresses item 5 of feast-dev#6907. They were disabled deliberately, for backwards compatibility: an unset metric deserializes as "" while the constructor default is None, so a Field never compared equal to its own deserialized copy and every field lacking an explicit metric would have shown as changed on every feast plan. Fixing that asymmetry removes the reason for the exclusion. The normalization goes in __init__ rather than from_proto, because from_proto is not the only deserialization path: OnDemandFeatureView._parse_features_from_proto builds a Field straight from a proto message. Normalizing only from_proto left the two paths disagreeing, which surfaced as a projection for an aliased on-demand feature view failing to apply, since the comparison is also what BaseFeatureView.with_projection uses to check a projection's fields. With both attributes compared, a change to vector_search_metric from COSINE to L2, or flipping vector_index, is now visible to feast plan and apply. Previously such a change altered retrieval semantics while producing no diff. Verified no regressions by diffing failure names across the full unit suite before and after: 41 pre-existing failures on both sides, none introduced. Signed-off-by: hao-xu5 <hxu44@apple.com>
|
Codecov Report✅ All modified and coverable lines are covered by tests. Additional details and impacted files@@ Coverage Diff @@
## master #6934 +/- ##
=======================================
Coverage 48.64% 48.64%
=======================================
Files 427 427
Lines 53864 53864
Branches 7849 7849
=======================================
Hits 26204 26204
Misses 25792 25792
Partials 1868 1868
Continue to review full report in Codecov by Harness.
🚀 New features to boost your workflow:
|
ntkathole
pushed a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Oct 13, 2026
# [0.67.0](v0.66.0...v0.67.0) (2026-10-13) ### Bug Fixes * Allow dill 0.4 so UDF serialization works on Python 3.14 ([#6858](#6858)) ([139704f](139704f)) * Allow serving features while a feature view is MATERIALIZING ([#6789](#6789)) ([e2d7fe2](e2d7fe2)), closes [#6780](#6780) * Allowlist the pinned commit SHA flagged by detect-secrets ([4b81d18](4b81d18)) * Apply point-in-time filter correctly with the Polars backend ([#6992](#6992)) ([01224d0](01224d0)) * Authorize registry server writes before deserializing UDFs ([e0ef16e](e0ef16e)) * Automate versioned documentation publication ([#6763](#6763)) ([5ad5592](5ad5592)), closes [#6762](#6762) * Avoid NumPy generic-unit deprecation when importing feast.type_map ([5fea698](5fea698)) * Bind metrics, REST registry, ui, and lineage servers dual-stack ([#6886](#6886)) ([8d2773c](8d2773c)) * Bound Arrow Flight batch size in the offline server ([#6896](#6896)) ([d169238](d169238)) * Compute std and var correctly for tiled aggregations ([213a130](213a130)) * Convert PdfBytes values to protos like ImageBytes ([#6968](#6968)) ([af20fe4](af20fe4)) * Decode fixed_size_list as the matching Feast list value type ([#6944](#6944)) ([8cfe891](8cfe891)) * Do not log /metrics requests from the pre-fork metrics server thread ([7087f1f](7087f1f)), closes [#6928](#6928) * Don't return from finally blocks in REST registry helpers ([d7cb4d0](d7cb4d0)) * Encode non-finite floats in feature server JSON responses ([#6930](#6930)) ([211ecb8](211ecb8)) * Feature freshness logic updated ([#6765](#6765)) ([f0bc070](f0bc070)) * Fix monitoring auth ([015cc84](015cc84)) * Handle non-nanosecond timestamps in tiled aggregations ([b8989cb](b8989cb)) * Improve feature list column sizing ([#6793](#6793)) ([2573693](2573693)) * Include vector attributes in Field equality ([#6934](#6934)) ([298c3f6](298c3f6)) * Increase feast container probe timeouts to avoid false restarts ([e8dbd50](e8dbd50)) * Infer the tensor type from retrieved values in to_tensor ([a03e323](a03e323)) * Infer timestamps for datetime columns in any unit or timezone ([810391f](810391f)) * Infer vector width when vector_length is undeclared ([0056565](0056565)), closes [#6907](#6907) * Initialize auth managers in standalone lineage server ([#6873](#6873)) ([ecd0d38](ecd0d38)) * Keep a zero watermark delay threshold on a Kafka source ([e2e28c7](e2e28c7)) * Keep entity rows apart in the ibis point-in-time join ([a87c070](a87c070)) * Keep the BatchFeatureView type and settings when copying it ([#6989](#6989)) ([013fc57](013fc57)) * Keep tiling, offline and stream engine settings when copying a StreamFeatureView ([fac0f88](fac0f88)) * Limit tiled max and min aggregations to the window ([2583c45](2583c45)) * Load Milvus collections once instead of on every query ([#6882](#6882)) ([f9e91fa](f9e91fa)) * Make vector length validation reachable, schema-driven and vectorized ([#6909](#6909)) ([29af8c0](29af8c0)), closes [#6907](#6907) * Map INT32_LIST, PDF_BYTES and IMAGE_BYTES type names to their ValueType ([8c1e825](8c1e825)) * Map narrow and unsigned Arrow integer types to Feast value types ([#6960](#6960)) ([ae74360](ae74360)) * Map Spark smallint and tinyint columns to INT32 ([9d42729](9d42729)) * Map SQL Server bigint to INT64 and float to DOUBLE ([6d15533](6d15533)) * Map Trino DECIMAL columns to pyarrow decimal128 ([155bc24](155bc24)) * Normalize Arrow-backed dtypes from Ray Dataset.to_pandas() for pyarrow >=25 compatibility ([#6916](#6916)) ([374f1d7](374f1d7)) * **operator:** Set grpc appProtocol on the offline Service port ([f9dcfb5](f9dcfb5)) * Pin expected tensor to same device in online retrieval test ([#6777](#6777)) ([1f2584d](1f2584d)) * Preserve an unset aggregation time window across a proto round-trip ([2000379](2000379)) * Preserve entity row order in precomputed reads ([ce37029](ce37029)) * Pull the MinIO test image from pgsty/minio ([fe27230](fe27230)) * Pull the MinIO test image from quay ([#6838](#6838)) ([367001b](367001b)) * Raise Trino monitoring query errors other than a missing table ([6161766](6161766)) * Read Kafka and Kinesis sources without a batch source from proto ([a620f5c](a620f5c)) * Read naive datetimes as UTC in UnixTimestamp values ([bc703d9](bc703d9)) * Record which storage class wrote a custom_storage payload ([#6988](#6988)) ([c0545f7](c0545f7)) * Refresh the SQL registry cache after deleting a data source ([66c55e3](66c55e3)) * Refresh the SQL registry cache after deleting a permission ([6b212f5](6b212f5)) * Reject unknown resource types and actions in the REST permission API ([a5eaa36](a5eaa36)) * Remove pip install command from Redis GLIDE docstring ([66ff990](66ff990)) * Remove runtime pip install hints from mlflow errors ([dd9f099](dd9f099)) * Remove unsupported vector_len from PostgreSQL tutorial config ([fcc9a85](fcc9a85)) * Repair Chronon operator validation and Pixi CI setup ([#6947](#6947)) ([3710f78](3710f78)) * Report Dask monitoring read errors instead of no data ([81673d9](81673d9)) * Resolve feature view batch source name against registry ([f8883d0](f8883d0)) * Restrict UI server CORS to trusted origins ([#6986](#6986)) ([5e7ef3e](5e7ef3e)) * Return feature_view_metadata from the REST feature server ([#6927](#6927)) ([bc5aeef](bc5aeef)) * Serve aliased on demand feature views in feature services ([823b92e](823b92e)) * Snapshot tag filters in registry cache keys ([81e1546](81e1546)) * Stabilize materialization checks across hour boundaries ([#6948](#6948)) ([acadb17](acadb17)) * Stop the Couchbase online store reporting failed writes as written ([b3f3c98](b3f3c98)) * Support SQL registry dump ([b60f9c7](b60f9c7)) * Treat datetimes with a None utcoffset as naive ([687bee8](687bee8)) * Unwrap SecretStr tokens when building Trino auth objects ([#6771](#6771)) ([922db5c](922db5c)) * Use a valid ShuffleStrategy for the Ray DatasetContext ([6259f5c](6259f5c)) * Use do_exchange for offline server reads to support HPA ([bae07fc](bae07fc)) * Use group_by in Polars backend aggregation ([#6965](#6965)) ([7b9fad2](7b9fad2)) * Use upstream kubectl image as feast-operator CronJob default ([d6cc1dc](d6cc1dc)) * Use UTC end bound and correct docs for disable_event_timestamp ([#6956](#6956)) ([cc07c82](cc07c82)), closes [#6936](#6936) ### Features * Add a non-JVM read path for Lance data sources ([#6943](#6943)) ([e2a53bb](e2a53bb)), closes [#6925](#6925) [#5782](#5782) [#6909](#6909) * Add a non-JVM write path for Lance data sources ([#6945](#6945)) ([f754323](f754323)), closes [#6943](#6943) [#6909](#6909) * Add Chronon online and offline store integrations ([#6188](#6188)) ([dd059c6](dd059c6)) * Add consistency_level to the Milvus online store config ([97296c1](97296c1)) * Add dualStack server option to the Feast operator ([#6887](#6887)) ([725a147](725a147)), closes [#6977](#6977) * Add Lance optional dependencies ([#6958](#6958)) ([20bc993](20bc993)) * Add LanceFormat table format with version/tag pinning ([1196e22](1196e22)), closes [#5650](#5650) * Add MLflow as a first-class offline DataSource for Feast ([#6702](#6702)) ([3667772](3667772)) * Add optional GLIDE client for Redis online reads ([#6870](#6870)) ([6e9a532](6e9a532)) * Add quality monitoring features for Trino offline store ([#6779](#6779)) ([9340545](9340545)) * Add SavedDatasetLanceStorage ([1118d3e](1118d3e)) * Add standalone MCP server as a first-class component ([0efab5c](0efab5c)), closes [python-keycloak#623](https://github.com/python-keycloak/issues/623) * Add structured audit logging for MCP feature server ([#6456](#6456)) ([640ac70](640ac70)) * Add Trino compute engine for batch retrieval and materialization ([#6898](#6898)) ([11a47b4](11a47b4)) * Batch Postgres online reads across feature views ([#6832](#6832)) ([514bee7](514bee7)), closes [#3259](#3259) * **bigtable:** Make write batch size and concurrency configurable ([#6847](#6847)) ([5388522](5388522)) * Bucket feature count labels in latency metrics ([#6811](#6811)) ([d9ea120](d9ea120)) * Expose runtime version in Feast UI ([#6843](#6843)) ([fa8f06b](fa8f06b)) * Make Milvus index and search params configurable ([ef743ff](ef743ff)) * Offline write batch for IcebergSource ([5be5ed0](5be5ed0)) * OpenLineage consumer improvements - dataset versioning, column lineage, ownership ([69f294e](69f294e)) * **operator:** Add tolerations and nodeSelector to the FeatureStore CR ([#6741](#6741)) ([03dac6f](03dac6f)) * Serve the MCP server dual-stack on --host :: ([4fc9726](4fc9726)) * Support Milvus partition keys in the Milvus online store ([0ed3285](0ed3285)) * Support token, uri and db_name in the Milvus online store ([c5efecd](c5efecd)) * Version-pinning for FeatureService (online + offline) ([#6718](#6718)) ([787845a](787845a)) ### Performance Improvements * Avoid pandas copy in Spark reads ([#6878](#6878)) ([4771156](4771156)) * Decouple metrics HTTP server into a dedicated child process ([#6855](#6855)) ([0b621de](0b621de)) * Reduce online serving hot-path overhead from metrics and audit logging ([5ee7ee3](5ee7ee3))
ntkathole
added a commit
to opendatahub-io/feast
that referenced
this pull request
Oct 14, 2026
* fix: Increase feast container probe timeouts to avoid false restarts Signed-off-by: Srihari <svenkata@redhat.com> * chore: Remove unused hermeto offline tree and sdist requirement locks (feast-dev#6987) * chore: Remove unused multicloud hermeto offline build tree Drop sdk/python/feast/infra/feature_servers/multicloud/offline/, which only supported local hermeto/arrow-from-source and RPM lock offline image builds and is unused by Makefile CI, GitHub Actions, or the standard feature-server Dockerfiles. Also clear related .secrets.baseline entries. Signed-off-by: ntkathole <nikhilkathole2683@gmail.com> Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * chore: Drop unused minimal-sdist requirement locks Remove py3.10–3.12 minimal-sdist(-build) lockfiles, stop generating them in lock-python-dependencies-all, and delete the minimal-sdist-build extra. They only supported hermeto build-from-sdist offline image builds. Signed-off-by: ntkathole <nikhilkathole2683@gmail.com> Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * chore: Refresh pixi.lock after removing minimal-sdist-build Keep pixi install --locked in sync with the pyproject.toml optional dependency change so ray/duckdb CI environments can install. Signed-off-by: ntkathole <nikhilkathole2683@gmail.com> Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> --------- Signed-off-by: ntkathole <nikhilkathole2683@gmail.com> Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * chore(release): release 0.67.0 # [0.67.0](feast-dev/feast@v0.66.0...v0.67.0) (2026-10-13) ### Bug Fixes * Allow dill 0.4 so UDF serialization works on Python 3.14 ([feast-dev#6858](feast-dev#6858)) ([139704f](feast-dev@139704f)) * Allow serving features while a feature view is MATERIALIZING ([feast-dev#6789](feast-dev#6789)) ([e2d7fe2](feast-dev@e2d7fe2)), closes [feast-dev#6780](feast-dev#6780) * Allowlist the pinned commit SHA flagged by detect-secrets ([4b81d18](feast-dev@4b81d18)) * Apply point-in-time filter correctly with the Polars backend ([feast-dev#6992](feast-dev#6992)) ([01224d0](feast-dev@01224d0)) * Authorize registry server writes before deserializing UDFs ([e0ef16e](feast-dev@e0ef16e)) * Automate versioned documentation publication ([feast-dev#6763](feast-dev#6763)) ([5ad5592](feast-dev@5ad5592)), closes [feast-dev#6762](feast-dev#6762) * Avoid NumPy generic-unit deprecation when importing feast.type_map ([5fea698](feast-dev@5fea698)) * Bind metrics, REST registry, ui, and lineage servers dual-stack ([feast-dev#6886](feast-dev#6886)) ([8d2773c](feast-dev@8d2773c)) * Bound Arrow Flight batch size in the offline server ([feast-dev#6896](feast-dev#6896)) ([d169238](feast-dev@d169238)) * Compute std and var correctly for tiled aggregations ([213a130](feast-dev@213a130)) * Convert PdfBytes values to protos like ImageBytes ([feast-dev#6968](feast-dev#6968)) ([af20fe4](feast-dev@af20fe4)) * Decode fixed_size_list as the matching Feast list value type ([feast-dev#6944](feast-dev#6944)) ([8cfe891](feast-dev@8cfe891)) * Do not log /metrics requests from the pre-fork metrics server thread ([7087f1f](feast-dev@7087f1f)), closes [feast-dev#6928](feast-dev#6928) * Don't return from finally blocks in REST registry helpers ([d7cb4d0](feast-dev@d7cb4d0)) * Encode non-finite floats in feature server JSON responses ([feast-dev#6930](feast-dev#6930)) ([211ecb8](feast-dev@211ecb8)) * Feature freshness logic updated ([feast-dev#6765](feast-dev#6765)) ([f0bc070](feast-dev@f0bc070)) * Fix monitoring auth ([015cc84](feast-dev@015cc84)) * Handle non-nanosecond timestamps in tiled aggregations ([b8989cb](feast-dev@b8989cb)) * Improve feature list column sizing ([feast-dev#6793](feast-dev#6793)) ([2573693](feast-dev@2573693)) * Include vector attributes in Field equality ([feast-dev#6934](feast-dev#6934)) ([298c3f6](feast-dev@298c3f6)) * Increase feast container probe timeouts to avoid false restarts ([e8dbd50](feast-dev@e8dbd50)) * Infer the tensor type from retrieved values in to_tensor ([a03e323](feast-dev@a03e323)) * Infer timestamps for datetime columns in any unit or timezone ([810391f](feast-dev@810391f)) * Infer vector width when vector_length is undeclared ([0056565](feast-dev@0056565)), closes [feast-dev#6907](feast-dev#6907) * Initialize auth managers in standalone lineage server ([feast-dev#6873](feast-dev#6873)) ([ecd0d38](feast-dev@ecd0d38)) * Keep a zero watermark delay threshold on a Kafka source ([e2e28c7](feast-dev@e2e28c7)) * Keep entity rows apart in the ibis point-in-time join ([a87c070](feast-dev@a87c070)) * Keep the BatchFeatureView type and settings when copying it ([feast-dev#6989](feast-dev#6989)) ([013fc57](feast-dev@013fc57)) * Keep tiling, offline and stream engine settings when copying a StreamFeatureView ([fac0f88](feast-dev@fac0f88)) * Limit tiled max and min aggregations to the window ([2583c45](feast-dev@2583c45)) * Load Milvus collections once instead of on every query ([feast-dev#6882](feast-dev#6882)) ([f9e91fa](feast-dev@f9e91fa)) * Make vector length validation reachable, schema-driven and vectorized ([feast-dev#6909](feast-dev#6909)) ([29af8c0](feast-dev@29af8c0)), closes [feast-dev#6907](feast-dev#6907) * Map INT32_LIST, PDF_BYTES and IMAGE_BYTES type names to their ValueType ([8c1e825](feast-dev@8c1e825)) * Map narrow and unsigned Arrow integer types to Feast value types ([feast-dev#6960](feast-dev#6960)) ([ae74360](feast-dev@ae74360)) * Map Spark smallint and tinyint columns to INT32 ([9d42729](feast-dev@9d42729)) * Map SQL Server bigint to INT64 and float to DOUBLE ([6d15533](feast-dev@6d15533)) * Map Trino DECIMAL columns to pyarrow decimal128 ([155bc24](feast-dev@155bc24)) * Normalize Arrow-backed dtypes from Ray Dataset.to_pandas() for pyarrow >=25 compatibility ([feast-dev#6916](feast-dev#6916)) ([374f1d7](feast-dev@374f1d7)) * **operator:** Set grpc appProtocol on the offline Service port ([f9dcfb5](feast-dev@f9dcfb5)) * Pin expected tensor to same device in online retrieval test ([feast-dev#6777](feast-dev#6777)) ([1f2584d](feast-dev@1f2584d)) * Preserve an unset aggregation time window across a proto round-trip ([2000379](feast-dev@2000379)) * Preserve entity row order in precomputed reads ([ce37029](feast-dev@ce37029)) * Pull the MinIO test image from pgsty/minio ([fe27230](feast-dev@fe27230)) * Pull the MinIO test image from quay ([feast-dev#6838](feast-dev#6838)) ([367001b](feast-dev@367001b)) * Raise Trino monitoring query errors other than a missing table ([6161766](feast-dev@6161766)) * Read Kafka and Kinesis sources without a batch source from proto ([a620f5c](feast-dev@a620f5c)) * Read naive datetimes as UTC in UnixTimestamp values ([bc703d9](feast-dev@bc703d9)) * Record which storage class wrote a custom_storage payload ([feast-dev#6988](feast-dev#6988)) ([c0545f7](feast-dev@c0545f7)) * Refresh the SQL registry cache after deleting a data source ([66c55e3](feast-dev@66c55e3)) * Refresh the SQL registry cache after deleting a permission ([6b212f5](feast-dev@6b212f5)) * Reject unknown resource types and actions in the REST permission API ([a5eaa36](feast-dev@a5eaa36)) * Remove pip install command from Redis GLIDE docstring ([66ff990](feast-dev@66ff990)) * Remove runtime pip install hints from mlflow errors ([dd9f099](feast-dev@dd9f099)) * Remove unsupported vector_len from PostgreSQL tutorial config ([fcc9a85](feast-dev@fcc9a85)) * Repair Chronon operator validation and Pixi CI setup ([feast-dev#6947](feast-dev#6947)) ([3710f78](feast-dev@3710f78)) * Report Dask monitoring read errors instead of no data ([81673d9](feast-dev@81673d9)) * Resolve feature view batch source name against registry ([f8883d0](feast-dev@f8883d0)) * Restrict UI server CORS to trusted origins ([feast-dev#6986](feast-dev#6986)) ([5e7ef3e](feast-dev@5e7ef3e)) * Return feature_view_metadata from the REST feature server ([feast-dev#6927](feast-dev#6927)) ([bc5aeef](feast-dev@bc5aeef)) * Serve aliased on demand feature views in feature services ([823b92e](feast-dev@823b92e)) * Snapshot tag filters in registry cache keys ([81e1546](feast-dev@81e1546)) * Stabilize materialization checks across hour boundaries ([feast-dev#6948](feast-dev#6948)) ([acadb17](feast-dev@acadb17)) * Stop the Couchbase online store reporting failed writes as written ([b3f3c98](feast-dev@b3f3c98)) * Support SQL registry dump ([b60f9c7](feast-dev@b60f9c7)) * Treat datetimes with a None utcoffset as naive ([687bee8](feast-dev@687bee8)) * Unwrap SecretStr tokens when building Trino auth objects ([feast-dev#6771](feast-dev#6771)) ([922db5c](feast-dev@922db5c)) * Use a valid ShuffleStrategy for the Ray DatasetContext ([6259f5c](feast-dev@6259f5c)) * Use do_exchange for offline server reads to support HPA ([bae07fc](feast-dev@bae07fc)) * Use group_by in Polars backend aggregation ([feast-dev#6965](feast-dev#6965)) ([7b9fad2](feast-dev@7b9fad2)) * Use upstream kubectl image as feast-operator CronJob default ([d6cc1dc](feast-dev@d6cc1dc)) * Use UTC end bound and correct docs for disable_event_timestamp ([feast-dev#6956](feast-dev#6956)) ([cc07c82](feast-dev@cc07c82)), closes [feast-dev#6936](feast-dev#6936) ### Features * Add a non-JVM read path for Lance data sources ([feast-dev#6943](feast-dev#6943)) ([e2a53bb](feast-dev@e2a53bb)), closes [feast-dev#6925](feast-dev#6925) [feast-dev#5782](feast-dev#5782) [feast-dev#6909](feast-dev#6909) * Add a non-JVM write path for Lance data sources ([feast-dev#6945](feast-dev#6945)) ([f754323](feast-dev@f754323)), closes [feast-dev#6943](feast-dev#6943) [feast-dev#6909](feast-dev#6909) * Add Chronon online and offline store integrations ([feast-dev#6188](feast-dev#6188)) ([dd059c6](feast-dev@dd059c6)) * Add consistency_level to the Milvus online store config ([97296c1](feast-dev@97296c1)) * Add dualStack server option to the Feast operator ([feast-dev#6887](feast-dev#6887)) ([725a147](feast-dev@725a147)), closes [feast-dev#6977](feast-dev#6977) * Add Lance optional dependencies ([feast-dev#6958](feast-dev#6958)) ([20bc993](feast-dev@20bc993)) * Add LanceFormat table format with version/tag pinning ([1196e22](feast-dev@1196e22)), closes [feast-dev#5650](feast-dev#5650) * Add MLflow as a first-class offline DataSource for Feast ([feast-dev#6702](feast-dev#6702)) ([3667772](feast-dev@3667772)) * Add optional GLIDE client for Redis online reads ([feast-dev#6870](feast-dev#6870)) ([6e9a532](feast-dev@6e9a532)) * Add quality monitoring features for Trino offline store ([feast-dev#6779](feast-dev#6779)) ([9340545](feast-dev@9340545)) * Add SavedDatasetLanceStorage ([1118d3e](feast-dev@1118d3e)) * Add standalone MCP server as a first-class component ([0efab5c](feast-dev@0efab5c)), closes [python-keycloak#623](https://github.com/python-keycloak/issues/623) * Add structured audit logging for MCP feature server ([feast-dev#6456](feast-dev#6456)) ([640ac70](feast-dev@640ac70)) * Add Trino compute engine for batch retrieval and materialization ([feast-dev#6898](feast-dev#6898)) ([11a47b4](feast-dev@11a47b4)) * Batch Postgres online reads across feature views ([feast-dev#6832](feast-dev#6832)) ([514bee7](feast-dev@514bee7)), closes [feast-dev#3259](feast-dev#3259) * **bigtable:** Make write batch size and concurrency configurable ([feast-dev#6847](feast-dev#6847)) ([5388522](feast-dev@5388522)) * Bucket feature count labels in latency metrics ([feast-dev#6811](feast-dev#6811)) ([d9ea120](feast-dev@d9ea120)) * Expose runtime version in Feast UI ([feast-dev#6843](feast-dev#6843)) ([fa8f06b](feast-dev@fa8f06b)) * Make Milvus index and search params configurable ([ef743ff](feast-dev@ef743ff)) * Offline write batch for IcebergSource ([5be5ed0](feast-dev@5be5ed0)) * OpenLineage consumer improvements - dataset versioning, column lineage, ownership ([69f294e](feast-dev@69f294e)) * **operator:** Add tolerations and nodeSelector to the FeatureStore CR ([feast-dev#6741](feast-dev#6741)) ([03dac6f](feast-dev@03dac6f)) * Serve the MCP server dual-stack on --host :: ([4fc9726](feast-dev@4fc9726)) * Support Milvus partition keys in the Milvus online store ([0ed3285](feast-dev@0ed3285)) * Support token, uri and db_name in the Milvus online store ([c5efecd](feast-dev@c5efecd)) * Version-pinning for FeatureService (online + offline) ([feast-dev#6718](feast-dev#6718)) ([787845a](feast-dev@787845a)) ### Performance Improvements * Avoid pandas copy in Spark reads ([feast-dev#6878](feast-dev#6878)) ([4771156](feast-dev@4771156)) * Decouple metrics HTTP server into a dedicated child process ([feast-dev#6855](feast-dev#6855)) ([0b621de](feast-dev@0b621de)) * Reduce online serving hot-path overhead from metrics and audit logging ([5ee7ee3](feast-dev@5ee7ee3)) --------- Signed-off-by: Srihari <svenkata@redhat.com> Signed-off-by: ntkathole <nikhilkathole2683@gmail.com> Co-authored-by: Srihari <svenkata@redhat.com> Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> Co-authored-by: feast-ci-bot <feast-ci-bot@willem.co>
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Addresses item 5 of #6907:
Field.__eq__ignoresvector_indexandvector_search_metric, so a change that alters retrieval semantics produces no diff infeast plan/apply.Why they were disabled, and why that reason is now gone
I traced this before changing it. Commit
1035cd4abfrom #4855:That was the right call at the time. The same commit also switched
from_protofromHasFieldchecks togetattr(field_proto, 'vector_search_metric', ''), which introduced an asymmetry:With the comparison enabled, every field lacking an explicit metric would compare unequal to its own deserialized copy — so every
feast planwould report spurious changes. Commenting out the comparison was the cheap way to stop that.This PR fixes the asymmetry instead, which removes the reason for the exclusion.
The normalization belongs in
__init__, notfrom_protoMy first attempt normalized
from_proto. That was the wrong layer, and the test suite caught it: two tests intest_on_demand_pandas_transformation.pystarted failing withBaseFeatureView.with_projectionchecksfeature not in self.features, which is this same__eq__. Instrumenting the comparison showed the two sides disagreeing on exactly one attribute:from_protois not the only deserialization path —OnDemandFeatureView._parse_features_from_protobuilds aFielddirectly from a proto message and never calls it. Normalizing in__init__makes every construction path converge, including any added later:After that, both paths agree and the projection applies again.
Effect
Testing
Added to
test_eq_cross_type.py, which is already the module for equality semantics:test_field_eq_includes_vector_attributes— metric change andvector_indextoggle are detectedtest_field_survives_a_proto_round_trip— parametrized over plain / vector-without-metric / vector-with-metric; this is the backwards-compatibility guard, so it should keep passing forevertest_field_normalizes_an_empty_metric_to_none— pins the__init__-level normalization, and documents why that layer rather thanfrom_protoThe first and third fail against
masterand pass here. 26 passed in that module.For regressions I diffed failure names across the whole unit suite rather than comparing counts, since the suite has flaky members:
ruff checkclean,mypy feast/field.pyclean.Note on item 3 of #6907
Item 3 proposed requiring
vector_lengthwhenvector_index=True. I looked into it and that specific change is not viable: there are ~29 call sites declaringvector_index=Truewithoutvector_length, including Feast's ownfeast init -t ragand-t ray_ragtemplates, severalexamples/, and four online stores that deliberately fall back to512. Making it mandatory would break the onboarding path.I'll follow up separately with a non-breaking alternative — rather than skipping validation when
vector_lengthis unset, enforce internal consistency against the first row's width, which catches ragged vectors without requiring anyone to declare anything.